A Perfect Evil: Maggie O’Dell, Book 1

A Perfect EvilAuthor: Alex Kava
Book Name: A Perfect Evil
Series: Maggie O’Dell
Order: #1
Genre: Suspense/Romance
Rating:  Okay

Blurb:  The brutal murders of three young boys paralyze the citizens of Platte City, Nebraska. What’s worse is the grim realization that the man recently executed for the crimes was a copycat. When Sheriff Nick Morrelli is called to the scene of another grisly murder, it becomes clear that the real predator is still at large, waiting to kill again.

Morrelli understands the urgency of the case terrorizing his community, but it’s the experienced eye of FBI criminal profiler Maggie O’Dell that pinpoints the true nature of the evil behind the killings–a revelation made all the more horrific when Morrelli’s own nephew goes missing.

Maggie understands something else: the killer is enjoying himself, relishing his ability to stay one step ahead of her, making this case more personal by the hour. Because out there, watching, is a killer with a heart of pure and perfect evil.

Review:  It is reasonable to assume that there have been huge changes with regards to investigating and solving crimes between when this book was originally published and now, but basic common sense and police procedure surely wasn’t that inept nearly 10 years ago.  If it was, then I cannot imagine that a single crime was ever solved or that every single person behind bars is innocent.

Every single thing that came up in this with regards to the investigation, how the crime scenes or evidence collection were handled, even just general common sense blew my mind at how utterly unprofessional it all seemed.  Maggie is supposedly a profiler, but she never actually gives the police a profile.  Apparently she has one, because she keeps telling Morrelli how different people don’t fit it, but she never actually presents one.  Morrelli is a joke in every sense of the word.  And in the end, after watching every single thing happen in this book like it is a three stooges act, the killer still isn’t caught and they have lots of circumstantial evidence against lots of other people (who will be getting charged on that thread of evidence) and the killer walks free.

The romantic aspect in this feels just as inappropriate and unprofessional as the job aspect.  Sorry, but a guy that can’t keep it in his pants and is thinking about getting it on, even when his own nephew is kidnapped is crazy.  Maggie, the FBI profiler, getting distracted by the typical jerk jock?  Makes her look like a stupid ditz, not someone who is smart enough to have a high level degree and job like that.

I don’t know that there is a single thing about this book that worked for me, there was so much that was just wrong.  Even if I were to consider some of my issues being irrelevant because of a dated version of crime fighting, this still wasn’t that great.


Author: TJ Fox

I am a slightly sane artist, amateur photographer, book addict, wife, mom and raging introvert. I have more hobbies than I can count, so it is beyond shocking that I manage to find time to do any of them, let alone most of them and still have time to do anything else. Of all the talents I claim, writing wasn’t one of them until my muse dropped the idea for a book on my head.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.